George Bush. No Longer Defensible
A lot of things will be said of George Bush’s presidency once he leaves office. Among the most scathing will be things said by republicans who have to hold their tongues during this election season else they jeopardize party nominee John McCain’s chances.
Put bluntly, Bush’s presidency has been a failure. A failure of leadership. The heretofore cardinal credential of the republican party.
Bush failed us in four ways: His selection of Dick Cheney as vice president, the Iraq war, Hurricane Katrina, and the $700 billion bailout of the financial markets.
First, Dick Cheney. There is nothing inherently wrong with Cheney. He is a strong leadership kind of guy with more smartz than most people. Bush was wise to choose him to be vice president during the first term. He blundered in keeping for the second.
By keeping Dick Cheney aboard during the second term Bush squandered the opportunity to grow a viable replacement and erstwhile head of the republican party for the 2008 elections. Now republicans have John McCain: An old man who is running like some 19th century populist candidate and away from his own political party to have a chance at beating a borderline socialist for the most powerful job in the world. This isn’t to suggest that any VP would not necessarily share in Bush’s own low approval ratings - - but at least the party would have a leader, like him or leave him, who might have had a chance like Al Gore did after eight years of Clinton.
Second, the war in Iraq. He got us bogged down in a protracted conflict that should have been put to bed within two years. Why didn’t that happen? Because of Bush’s dogged loyalty to people who were not up to the tasks at hand. Start with Donald Rumsfeld.
Rumsfeld butted heads with his generals in the Pentagon arguing for a lighter, faster Army and against more boots on the ground to secure territory already won. The result was a growing, festering and dangerous insurgency that couldn’t be handled by the available troops that were already stretched thin with commitments in Afghanistan and around the world. Unprecedented over-use of the National Guard and the Reserves broke morale as well as the bank. Then there was inept American civilian leadership in Baghdad that threw gasoline on the fire of occupation, discontent and mistrust.
Incredibly, Bush fired Rumsfeld the day after republicans lost majorities in the house and senate by the razor thinnest of margins in 2006. Had Bush sacked Rumsfeld a week before the election, it might have made a difference in at least a few of those close races. It was awful timing and, in retrospect, looked like a presidential retreat to the new Democrat majority demands to pull out of Iraq. If it wasn’t for General David Petraeus, apparently the only exception among a slew of manager-class generals who still don’t understand how to close the deal when it comes to winning wars, this country would be holding its head in shame in another defeat at the hands of yet another inferior foe.
Hurricane Katrina. While telling his completely inept FEMA chief to keep up the good work, the city of New Orleans turned into Haiti for a couple of weeks. Outdated rules and federal regulations that technically kept the feds from moving in immediately after the disaster struck compounded problems with equally inept and incompetent state and local leadership on site. Chaos, confusion and pandemonium was the order of the day. Not to mention formaldehyde riddled trailers for victims to live in. America sends more resources faster to third world for earthquake relief than it sent to New Orleans within 48 hours of Katrina. Another high profile failure by another loyal Bush appointee.
And just when Bush thought he could quietly slip out the back door with the lowest approval ratings of any president since Richard Nixon, along comes the collapse of the financial markets.
By all measures, Bush saw this one coming. His administration made a few tepid attempts to bring Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac problems to the democrats’ attention, but the republicans slinked away when they were told to go away. Bush chose not to sound the alarm on Main Street. And instead of killing off wasteful spending that resulted in a near doubling of the national debt on his watch, Bush birthed a new entitlement program (prescription drugs for seniors) that promises to bring the whole medicare house of card down much sooner than it would have. The clock is ticking on that one. And still no alarm from the Bush administration that Main Street can clearly hear.
Bush also had the chance to change social security but gave up after only a few short rounds of light sparing. Instead he’s kicked the can down the road to some future schlep president. With luck that might be Barack Obama and not some hapless republican.
The final straw was Secretary of the Treasury Paulsen (yet another failed high-profile Bush appointee) running to Congress on his knees with what’s left of his hair on fire screaming for a $700 billion bailout of Wall Street before the whole economy collapses.
Whether the magnitude and gravity of the ‘sky is falling’ scenario is accurate or not, Bush had an opportunity to meet with presidential nominee, McCain and republican congressional leaders to craft a gameplan that would make the republicans the champions of Main Street. A plan that not only presented the problem in simple, understandable terms, but sketched out palatable solutions which do not threaten the free market capitalist system those soldiers in Iraq presumably died for.
But alas, he did not. Instead he dumped the problem on the whole congress like a bucket of cold piss. And along with Paulsen, he has joined in the screaming for $700 billion for Wall Street.
I voted for George Bush. Twice. I thought he was better than the alternatives both times. I still think he was. Unfortunately, once he got to the “big show” he figuratively started looking at his watch just like his old man literally did in that debate with Bill Clinton that helped seal his defeat. That and his proclaimed problem getting that vision thing.' I guess the acorn really doesn't fall very far from the tree, does it?
Unfortunately, republicans, by Bush design, do not have a party leader. Instead it has a poll-driven geriatric populist who admits he doesn't understand anything about economics! A candidate, ironically, who is disliked by most of his republican senate peers and whose best legislative friends in that body are liberal democrats. Thanks George. We could have had a vice president who could have been a contender.
Katrina will always be a can tied to republicans’ tail that will clank with every step it takes for the next 20 years. Great job, Brownie!
Iraq may be the only thing that comes off clean unless, of course, the democrats gain control of the White House in 2008. If they do I would expect by February 2009 the life support plug will be pulled and we’ll watch Iraq turn into a 12th century nightmare overnight.
Finally, the $700 billion bailout. By not guiding this catastrophe and getting the republicans on the same page before the alarm bell was sounded Bush has all but assured our economy takes a giant step into socialism: A system where government bureaucrats dictate the market and we soon go to five year agriculture and production plans just like the old Soviet Union did before it died.
Thanks, George. This is exactly the way Hugo Chavez runs Venezuela!
I used to defend George Bush. I can’t any more. I hope he withdraws into obscurity and that we never see or hear from him again. A worse fate than even those losers Gore or Kerry got.
And I will never vote for a so called ‘compassionate conservative’ ever again.